Home / Subaru / Subaru Forester (EJ25) / 2.5L (NA)
VERDICT · SAME HEAD GASKET CHECK, LESS TURBO-RELATED STRESS

Subaru Forester (EJ25) 2.5L (NA)
is it a safe used buy?

The standard, naturally aspirated trim on this Forester generation — the same EJ25 family and the same documented head gasket design as the turbocharged XT.

GENERATION2nd gen, 2.5X (2003–2008)
ENGINE2.5L (NA)
POWER173 hp
USED PRICE$5,500–10,500

How the engine fits this car

The standard, naturally aspirated trim on this Forester generation — the same EJ25 family and the same documented head gasket design as the turbocharged XT.

Without boost-related heat layered on top, this version runs under somewhat gentler conditions than the turbo, though the gasket concern itself still applies.

Subaru Forester (EJ25)-specific pros and cons

This is about the car itself — for engine-specific failure points, see the dedicated engine page below.

WHAT HOLDS UP WELL

  • Genuinely capable, practical all-wheel-drive SUV with real everyday versatility
  • Runs cooler than the turbocharged XT trim of the same generation
  • A confirmed, repaired example is a meaningfully safer, well-understood buy
  • Lower purchase price than turbocharged XT trims

WHAT TO WATCH

  • External head gasket coolant leak, detailed on the engine page, is a genuine concern shared with the turbo version
  • Noticeably less power than the turbocharged XT trim
  • Age-related wear on suspension, electrics and trim is a bigger factor at this age
  • Resale demand has softened somewhat, reflecting broader awareness of the issue

Pricing on the used market

Mileage band
Typical price
What to expect
Under 100,000 mi
$8,500–10,500
Lower-mileage, ideally with full service records
100,000–150,000 mi
$6,500–8,500
Sweet spot, verify head gasket history
150,000+ mi
$5,500–6,500
Treat with real caution without documented repair

The engine itself

This naturally aspirated Forester shares its EJ25 engine, and that engine's head gasket concern, with the turbocharged XT trim. The full checklist lives on the shared engine page.

FULL ENGINE BREAKDOWNSubaru 2.5L EJ25 Flat-Four — Reliable or Not →

Pre-purchase checklist for this generation

Ask whether the head gasket has been proactively replaced, and get documentation if so.

Check for a sweet coolant smell or visible seep near the lower edge of the cylinder head.

Check coolant level consistency over a few days if possible.