Home / Tesla / Tesla Model S / 70D/85D/90D
VERDICT · TWO SEPARATE CHECKS, BOTH ESSENTIAL

Tesla Model S 70D/85D/90D
is it a safe used buy?

The car that launched Tesla as a serious automaker — genuinely groundbreaking when new, now old enough that both the MCU1 and early drive unit checklists on this site apply at full force.

GENERATION1st gen, pre-refresh (2012–2015)
POWERTRAINSingle or dual motor
RANGE (NEW)208–270 mi (EPA)
USED PRICE$17,000–30,000

How the engine fits this car

This generation represents Tesla's first-generation hardware across the board — battery, drive unit, and infotainment computer all reflect the company's earliest production engineering, before the running revisions covered on several of this site's dedicated pages.

Unlike a conventional used car where the engine is the main concern, this car asks you to check three largely independent systems — battery health, drive unit noise, and MCU1 status — each of which can be fine or problematic independent of the others.

Tesla Model S-specific pros and cons

This is about the car itself — for engine-specific failure points, see the dedicated engine page below.

WHAT HOLDS UP WELL

  • Battery degradation data, detailed on the shared battery page, is genuinely reassuring even on this early generation
  • Groundbreaking driving experience and build quality for its era that still holds up well today
  • A thoroughly checked example (battery, drive unit, and MCU1 all verified or addressed) is a known, reasonable buy
  • Significant depreciation makes this one of the most accessible ways into a genuinely capable long-range EV

WHAT TO WATCH

  • MCU1 eMMC wear, detailed in full on its own dedicated page, is a significant concern on unaddressed examples
  • Early drive unit whine, detailed on its own page, is a documented concern on a subset of examples
  • Panel gap and build quality inconsistencies were more common on this earliest production era than later Teslas
  • Finding a specialist familiar with all three systems' nuances takes more effort than a mainstream used-car purchase

Pricing on the used market

Documented history
Typical price
What to expect
MCU upgraded, drive unit checked, good battery health
$25,000–30,000
Meaningfully safer, thoroughly verified
Partial documentation, no major symptoms
$20,000–25,000
Budget for the MCU upgrade proactively
Unknown history or symptoms present
$17,000–20,000
Treat with real caution

The engine itself

This Model S is the defining application of both the early drive unit and MCU1 covered on their own dedicated pages — both checklists should be treated as essential before buying.

FULL ENGINE BREAKDOWNTesla MCU1 eMMC Failure — Reliable or Not →

Other engines in this generation

This car's drive unit has its own, separately documented set of concerns worth checking alongside the MCU.

Pre-purchase checklist for this generation

Run a battery health check comparing current range to the original EPA rating for this specific configuration, per the guidance on the battery page.

Ask whether the MCU has been upgraded, and test the touchscreen thoroughly for responsiveness and app performance.

Listen for drive unit whine under both acceleration and regenerative braking during the test drive.